Friday, August 23, 2013

Righteous Indignation

Lately, I have heard several news stories that have shocked and saddened me.  I want to believe in basic human decency,in charity, and love of neighbor, but sometimes feel like evidence is contrary to my preferred view.
I know terrible aspects of society exist, but usually choose not to focus on them.  I feel they are anomalies and that people are generally good and decent.  Though, there are some stories lately that have threatened my world view.  I focus on these stores in this post because I think it is important that we as a civil society become outraged by these events.
Story 1: Texas - A 13 year old foster child runs away from her foster home.  She accepts a ride from three men, is taken to an apartment and repeatedly raped by up to 10 different men through the night.  Full story: http://www.theblaze.com/stories/2013/07/24/immigration-detainers-placed-on-two-mexican-men-charged-in-horrific-gang-rape-of-13-year-old-texas-girl/
Story 2: Oklahoma - A 23 year old college baseball player from Australia was shot in the back while walking down the street.  He was killed by 3 teenage boys who claimed to be "bored" and therefore decided to "kill somebody." Full story: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/08/19/christopher-lane-australian-baseball-player-dies_n_3782318.html
Story 3: Ontario, Canada - The family of a severely autistic child found an anonymous letter at their home.  The letter was full of hateful language putting down their child, calling him useless, unlovable, and suggesting the mother euthanize her son and allow scientists to harvest his organs.  Please read the full text of the letter, it is shocking.  Full story: http://www.theblaze.com/stories/2013/08/19/read-the-unbelievably-hateful-letter-sent-to-family-with-autistic-child-do-the-right-thing-and-move-or-euthanize-him/
Why did I choose these stories?  What links them to each other?  They all show a lack of respect for the human person.  The men in the first story lack respect for women and children.  The boys in the second, lack respect for human life and do not recognize moral consequences.  The woman in the 3rd story does not feel that a handicapped child or his family deserve to be treated with dignity or respect.
These events should outrage us, as decent citizens we should unite against this type of senseless violence.  I think they do outrage us, but are we giving them enough focus in the media? Are these events spurring us to discussions of causality or pointing us to a bigger flaw in the fabric of society?
It is said that you can tell the character of a man by how he treats those weaker than him.  We are a nation who sides with the underdog, we love the kid who stands up to the bully to protect the nerd, the hero who jumps on the subway track to save someone, the children who find victory and their place at the Special Olympics.
What type of character do the people in these news stories have?  Do the men who raped that poor girl have any decency?  Do the boys who killed that college student have a conscience?  Does the woman who wrote that letter have compassion?  These people are self-absorbed, concerned entirely with their own desires and comfort.  Their actions are cruel and evil.  In the first two cases the persons should be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law.  In the third she should be held accountable for her rude behavior and publicly shamed by her neighbors.
Allowing these news stories to come and go is not enough.  We need to be outraged.  We need to denounce these types of senseless acts of violence as wrong.  Our world is full of gray areas, but is there still right and wrong?  And do we still know what that is?
Detroit is no exception to these types of unfortunate events.  We recently had two homeless men killed in a hit and run, they were not hit once, but by two different cars, neither driver stopped to care for these men.  I am ashamed to live in a city where that would happen.  
There is decency left in our society though, and this gives me hope.  One of those men used to sit in his wheel chair by the freeway entrance, since his death someone placed his wheel chair on that corner and people have placed flowers and trinkets in his honor and written messages on the chair.  The other man was a regular at Detroit Tiger's games, a bit of a local celebrity for fans.  Shirts were made up with this man's signature phrase ("Eat 'em up Tigers") and sold to cover funeral costs for the two men.  We are a good and decent people, but we need to remember this and express it more often.
Let us be: good, compassionate, loving, hopeful, helpful, and kind.  Let us build a world of respect and love for one another.  We are all different, but that is what makes life interesting and exciting.  How dull the world would be if we were all the same.
Different, but equal, no one of us is more important than another.  We have become a self-absorbed, self-obsessed culture, constantly on social media glorifying our own lives.  So many of us have lost our connection with other members of society, we have lost our sense of community, our respect for people, and the reality of responsibility and consequence.  
For me, I want to see all persons, of all walks of life, races, sexes, intelligence levels, physical ability, religions, etc. treated with the respect and decency they deserve.  I will not stop being outraged by the news stories I shared and I will not stop working for a world where these stories cease to exist.

Friday, August 16, 2013

Snap Judgement Episode 1: Anthony Stokes' Heart Transplant

I want this blog to be a dialog encouraging comments, discussion, argument, and critical thought.  Therefore I am introducing a new segment called "Snap Judgement."  In this recurring series I will present a news story, case study, or question for thought and discussion.  Please participate by leaving your opinion and thoughts on the topic in the comments section.  I will refrain from giving my opinion in the body of the text but participate in the discussion along with my readers.

Snap Judgement Episode 1: Anthony Stokes' Heart Transplant

This week an Atlanta, Georgia Children's Hospital made the news.  15 year old Anthony Stokes was diagnosed with an enlarged heart, the only cure is a heart transplant.  Without transplant Anthony was given 6 months to live.

The hospital initially refused to place Anthony's name on the transplant list.  The hospital listed "non-compliance" as the reason, feeling that Anthony was not likely to comply with the post-transplant medication or follow up schedule.  Anthony has a history of low grades and has had trouble with the law.

Anthony's family began an all out media blitz, telling their story to all who will listen.  The family claims that the hospital has no legitimate reason to believe the Anthony would be "non-compliant" as until his recent diagnosis he was in good health and has no history with the hospital.  The Stokes Family's story has captured the media's attention and this week the hospital's decision was reversed.

This is of course a very quick summary of the situation.  Other articles can be found here:
 https://www.google.com/search?hl=en&gl=us&tbm=nws&authuser=0&q=Anthony+Stokes

A few questions for discussion:

1) How do you feel about the recent trend of media involvement in transplant decisions?  Do you think the hospital reversal in this case, as well as the adult lung transplant in the 10yr old girl from earlier this summer, were directly related to the media taking up the fight of the families?

2) Do you think the hospital has a right to refuse transplant to patients with a history of non-compliance, or strong indicators that they will be non-compliant?  And if so, what indication for non-compliance would be justified?

I look forward to a lively debate and discussion on this topic.  Please remember to keep your comments, on topic, professional and edifying: no swearing, petty name calling, or personal attacks.  This is an avenue for wholesome, fair minded debate, and this author reserves the right to remove any comments she feels stifle debate or contain inappropriate content.  Thank you!

Friday, August 9, 2013

Dear Jhonny…

So, it’s been an interesting week in Major League Baseball; an historic take down of steroid abusers and one of my Tigers is among them.  It’s a 50 game suspension for Tiger’s shortstop, Jhonny Peralta, and over 200 games for New York Yankee, Alex Rodriguez (A-Rod). 

In total, 13 players were suspended for purchasing performance enhancing drugs (PEDs) through a Miami clinic.  This was the largest PED suspension in the history of baseball and many are praising Major League Baseball (MLB) management for their vigilance in cleaning up the sport.  I am not among those heaping praises.  Personally, I think the whole thing is for show and these players drew the short straw.

As fans we insist that our favorite sports get faster, better, and more exciting every year.  We want athletes of super human ability, but certainly don’t want them to take PEDs to get these abilities.  Dear sports fans…we can’t have it both ways.

Therefore, we must choose: do we want a pure, clean, wholesome sport with potentially fewer home runs, and less excitement, or do we accept the use of PEDs?

Until we answer this question honestly the game will never be “clean.”  Personally, I wouldn’t mind a PED free baseball game.  I tend to like sports in their non-enhanced form.  For instance, I find college basketball far more energetic and entertaining than the NBA games.  Is this true for the majority of fans however?

We say we don’t want PEDs in sports because they are unhealthy for the players.  The following is a list of side effects copied from the MayoClinic website:

Men may develop:
·         Prominent breasts
·         Baldness
·         Shrunken testicles
·         Infertility
·         Impotence

Women may develop:
·         A deeper voice
·         An enlarged clitoris
·         Increased body hair
·         Baldness
·         Infrequent or absent periods

Both men and women might experience:
·         Severe acne
·         Increased risk of tendinitis and tendon rupture
·         Liver abnormalities and tumors
·         Increased low-density lipoprotein (LDL) cholesterol (the "bad" cholesterol)
·         Decreased high-density lipoprotein (HDL) cholesterol (the "good" cholesterol)
·         High blood pressure (hypertension)
·         Heart and circulatory problems
·         Prostate gland enlargement
·         Aggressive behaviors, rage or violence
·         Psychiatric disorders, such as depression
·         Drug dependence
·         Infections or diseases such as HIV or hepatitis if you're injecting the drugs

Having read the effects, what are your thoughts?  Do we downgrade the game to protect the health of our boys?  Do we openly accept and endorse the use of steroids, sacrificing the health of our players and potentially teaching bad lessons to young impressionable fans?  Or do we maintain this “don’t ask, don’t tell” approach to steroid use, every so often catching a player or two for a sacrifice?


I am a woman of clear opinions, lines, and values.  I do not like half-hearted solutions and problems being swept under the rug.  If we do not care about steroid use we should stop looking for it.  If we do care, we should crack down hard and rid the game of PEDs for good.  This short term suspension for players involved with a single supplier being lauded as the great clean-up of baseball is garbage.  MLB, do it right or not at all..